Will Grigg sent another message to his doubters on Saturday. His two opportunist goals at Nottingham had hauled his team back into a game where they had clearly been second best. What a shame his efforts were wasted by abysmal defending giving Forest a win in time added on.
In fact neither team’s defence looked solid. Witnessing the quality of Forest’s midfield play and the movement of their forwards one could have got the impression that they will challenge for promotion. So often they sliced through the Wigan defence like a knife. They scored four, and could conceivably have doubled that tally. But they have defensive problems. Grigg’s two goals were prime examples of opportunism as the centre forward punished the home team defence for their sloppiness.
Wigan too played some attractive football. Alex Gilbey and Michael Jacobs supported Grigg from midfield and Shaun MacDonald gave a promising first half display sitting in front of the back four. But the defence looked shaky from the start.
Gary Caldwell had decided to continue with the experiment of playing Yanic Wildschut as a wing back, as he had in the second half against Birmingham in midweek. It proved to be an ill-judged move.
Not only was the Dutchman lost in the role, but Craig Morgan was left exposed. With so little protection from not only the wing back, but also the midfield, the captain looked a shadow of the player he was last season. Morgan struggled for pace against speedy attackers flooding his zone.
Given his contribution to last season’s title winning team few fans will openly criticise Morgan. Granted he never was the quickest of defenders, but he was able to use his experience to get into the right positions and make the best decisions. Some doubt that the captain is the right man to lead a defence in the Championship, but acknowledge that he is not alone in lacking pace in the Latics back line. The assertion is that a slow moving defence will have constant problems against the speedy forwards that so many Championship sides possess.
However, rarely will Morgan be as exposed as he was on Saturday. The failure of the midfield to protect the defence was a feature of the team’s performance. The absence of David Perkins was fully felt. Last season he was invaluable in covering his defence in deep positions, together with Max Power, whose defensive performance was found lacking at Nottingham. Moreover Morgan has been moved from his preferred position in the centre of the back three, where speed is an asset but an ability to read the game is paramount. Last season Morgan received one red card and seven yellows in 38 league appearances. He has picked up three yellows in the first four league games so far.
Having conceded four goals, despite another fine performance by keeper Adam Bogdan, the defence will inevitably take most of the blame. The decision to jettison Jason Pearce, who formed a formidable central defensive partnership with Morgan last season, continues to be questioned by the pundits. Should that partnership have been maintained, albeit in a higher division of football, where they would have been more tested by the pace and skills of Championship level forwards?
The use of Wildschut as a wing back was a speculative attacking ploy by Caldwell. Against a stubborn Birmingham defence defending their one goal lead Caldwell had withdrawn his wing backs and placed Michael Jacobs and Wildschut in those positions. It was a bold move, typical of what we have come to expect from the manager over the past year. There were times last season when Caldwell threw caution to the wind and risked his defence being badly exposed. On occasions he got caught out, with the opposition scoring from rapid counterattacks, but there were times when games were won as a result.
There are fans who prefer to see Latics play with a conventional back four, rather than with three centre backs and wing backs. The 3-5-2 or 3-4-3 played by Caldwell’s teams last year saw the wing backs pushed high up the field, almost like wingers. An inherent danger in any type of 3-5-2 or 3-4-3 formation is wing backs being caught far forward and centre backs having to deal with pacy wide players on the break.
It is a far cry from the days in the Premier League when Latics had two excellent wing backs in Emmerson Boyce and Jean Beausejour who were not pushed so far forward. The two were so good at stretching the play by hugging the touchline and making themselves available to receive the ball from defence and support attacks. However, both played key defensive roles , the back three becoming a back five as they dropped back. On Saturday Wildschut looked lost when Forest attacked and Luke Garbutt made more of an impression in attack than in defence.
The three game suspension suffered by the experienced Jake Buxton, together with a long term injury for Donervon Daniels, has reduced Caldwell’s options in the centre of defence. Following Buxton’s suspension Dan Burn was moved to the centre of the back line of three, with Morgan moving to the right.
With Buxton due to be available again for the match against QPR on Saturday, Caldwell might well opt for his experience on the right, with Morgan in the centre and Dan Burn on the left. Although the manager did not include the 18 year old Luke Burke from the start at Nottingham, when the young player came on he once again looked the part. Despite his tender years he is the complete wing back. Buxton’s return could also enable Stephen Warnock to return to his more familiar position of left wing back. A return to 4-3-3 is also a possibility with a back four of Burke, Buxton, Morgan and Warnock.
A settled defence is key to Wigan’s chances of success in the Championship. Up to this point they have a record of W1 D1 L2, with a total of 4 points. Last year’s League 1 winning team had exactly the same record this time last year, as did Uwe Rosler’s team the year before which got relegated. It is simply too early in the season to predict what will happen later. Moreover both league defeats up to this point have come through goals in time added on.
In the meantime Caldwell will look at establishing a settled defence with a midfield in front of it that takes its fair share of defensive responsibilities.
Love you guys and your pieces. Look forward to this email every week.
How do you all watch the matches from the US? I believe Latics Player on the club website is only active for viewers in the UK. I’d love to be able to watch the matches instead of seeing a game cast or following Twitter feeds.
Thanks for your comments.
Ned is in the US, but I am in the UK.
One would hope that the time will come when Latics games can be streamed on pay for view for overseas fans. But for the moment your access is going to be very limited. Having said that, the Blackburn match was shown live on Bein Sports in Australia, France and the US.
Not sure about Burn. Warnock has played in a back three before so I think that would be a better option considering he is not as slow as Burn and a better player all round. I personally liked the 3-4-3 system, but a back four is not a bad idea either. Is Nick Powell available? He should definitely start if fit.
Thank you very much for this column! I have been thinking about this subject since the Forest match. For me, the defensive problems all start with the Jason Pearce situation. With Pearce and Morgan both starting last season, we were undefeated in 20 league matches (W 13 D7). I still do not know if Pearce really wanted to move on, as it was reported he wanted to be closer to his family, or if Caldwell pushed him out, having already brought in Dan Burn. If the latter, then Caldwell has a lot of explaining to do, because he broke up a defensive partnership that was highly successful and had enough chemistry between them to carry on in the Championship. Burn remains a mystifying signing, my quick perusal of Fulham FC forums indicated they did not think very highly of him, and having seen him in action, he is so terrible with the ball at his feet that I am sure it compromises the entire defence. I suspect Burn was brought in primarily to defend set pieces, which was one of our weaknesses last season, but in the Championship, that skill is less of a priority than speed, quickness, tactical nous, and ball playing. All this said, it is clear to me that we need at least one more centre back, and possibly one more wingback, especially with Daniels and Knoyle out long term. Finally, what should not be overlooked in this discussion is our defensive midfield, as Perkins is aging, Power needs a strong partner to succeed, and while MacDonald seems a good addition, our only other defensive midfield option is Morsy, whom Caldwell for some unknown reason is apparently looking to ship out; I want Morsy to stay, but even if he does stay, I would want at least one more signing to shore up this group.